Why Does My Pool Smell Like Fish: Common Causes & Solutions

Image Source: quench.culligan.com

Why Does My Pool Smell Like Fish: Common Causes & Solutions

A pool that smells like fish is a common and unpleasant problem. The fishy odor in your swimming pool is most often caused by a chemical imbalance, specifically the presence of chloramines that have bonded with organic compounds.

Deciphering the Fishy Aroma: The Role of Chloramines

The typical “chlorine smell” you might associate with a swimming pool is actually the scent of chloramines. These are compounds formed when chlorine, added to sanitize your pool water, reacts with contaminants. While a healthy level of chloramines can produce a mild odor, a strong, fishy smell indicates a problem.

How Chloramines Form

Chlorine’s primary job is to kill bacteria, viruses, and other harmful microorganisms in your pool water. However, it also reacts with organic matter introduced into the pool. This organic matter can come from various sources:

• Human Contaminants: This is a major contributor. When people swim, they bring with them bodily fluids and substances such as urine, sweat, and dead skin cells. These organic compounds consume free chlorine. As free chlorine levels drop, the chlorine that’s left begins to react with these contaminants, forming chloramines.
• Organic Debris: Leaves, grass clippings, insects, and other organic debris that fall into the pool decompose over time. This decomposition process releases organic compounds that, when they come into contact with chlorine, contribute to chloramine formation.
• Sunscreen and Body Oils: Lotions, sunscreens, and natural body oils can also contribute to the organic load in your pool water, leading to the formation of chloramines.

The Chemistry Behind the Smell

When chlorine (hypochlorous acid) encounters nitrogen-containing compounds, it forms chloramines. Initially, these are called monochloramines. As more chlorine is added and reacts, dichloramines and then trichloramines are formed. It’s the trichloramines, in particular, that are volatile and release into the air, creating that potent, often fishy, odor.

The reaction can be simplified as:

Chlorine (Cl₂) + Nitrogenous Waste (e.g., ammonia) → Chloramines (e.g., NH₂Cl, NHCl₂, NCl₃) + Water (H₂O)

The stronger the smell, the higher the concentration of chloramines, and the less effective your free chlorine is at sanitizing the pool. A pool that smells strongly of fish is essentially telling you that your chlorine is busy reacting with contaminants instead of actively sanitizing.

Beyond Chloramines: Other Potential Culprits

While chloramines are the most common cause, other issues can contribute to a fishy or unpleasant pool smell.

Algae Bloom

An algae bloom can sometimes produce a musty or earthy odor, but in some cases, certain types of algae or the byproducts of their decay can create a more fish-like smell. Algae thrive in pools with poor water balance and insufficient chlorine levels.

• Conditions Favoring Algae:
  • Low chlorine levels.
  • High phosphate levels (nutrients for algae).
  • Warm water temperatures.
  • Lack of proper circulation.

If you notice a green or cloudy tint to your water along with the smell, algae is a likely contributor.

Water Imbalance

A significant water imbalance can exacerbate the chloramine issue. When your pool’s pH, alkalinity, or calcium hardness levels are off, the chlorine you add may not be as effective. This means it gets “used up” faster by contaminants, leading to a higher build-up of chloramines and a stronger odor.

• pH: Proper pH (typically 7.2-7.6) is crucial for chlorine to work effectively. If the pH is too high, chlorine is less potent. If it’s too low, it can cause irritation.
• Alkalinity: Total alkalinity acts as a buffer for pH. If alkalinity is too low, pH can fluctuate wildly, affecting chlorine’s performance.
• Calcium Hardness: While less directly related to smell, extremely low calcium hardness can contribute to corrosive water, which can impact pool equipment.

Poor Filtration and Circulation

Poor filtration and circulation are fundamental problems that allow contaminants to build up and thrive.

• Circulation: Water needs to move constantly to distribute sanitizing chemicals evenly and to bring contaminants to the filter. If your pump is not running long enough or if jets are blocked, dead spots can develop where organic matter accumulates and breaks down.
• Filtration: Your pool filter removes debris and impurities from the water. If the filter is dirty, clogged, or undersized, it cannot do its job effectively, allowing contaminants to remain in the water and react with chlorine.

Troubleshooting the Fishy Smell: Step-by-Step Solutions

Addressing a fishy pool smell requires a systematic approach.

Step 1: Test Your Water

This is the most critical first step. You need to know the current state of your pool water before you can effectively treat it.

• What to Test For:

  • Free Chlorine (FC)
  • Total Chlorine (TC)
  • Combined Chlorine (CC) / Chloramines
  • pH
  • Total Alkalinity (TA)
  • Calcium Hardness (CH)
  • Cyanuric Acid (CYA) – if you use stabilized chlorine (dichlor or trichlor)

• Tools: Use a reliable pool water test kit or test strips. Digital testers can also be very accurate.

Step 2: Shock Your Pool (Superchlorination)

Shocking your pool is the process of raising the chlorine level significantly for a short period to break down chloramines and kill any remaining bacteria or algae.

• Purpose: To oxidize contaminants and break the bond between chlorine and nitrogenous compounds, thus eliminating chloramines.
• When to Shock:
  • When you detect a strong chemical smell, especially a fishy one.
  • After heavy pool use.
  • After heavy rain.
  • If you notice cloudy water or the beginnings of an algae bloom.
• How to Shock:
  1. Ensure your water imbalance is corrected first (especially pH).
  2. Turn on the pool pump and ensure good circulation.
  3. Add the recommended amount of pool shock (usually liquid chlorine or granular shock like calcium hypochlorite). The amount will depend on your pool’s volume and the severity of the problem. For a fishy smell, you’ll likely need to add enough to bring the free chlorine level to 10 ppm or higher.
  4. Broadcast the shock evenly around the pool.
  5. Let the pump run continuously for at least 24 hours.
  6. Keep swimmers out of the pool until the free chlorine level drops back to a safe swimming level (typically 1-4 ppm).

Step 3: Address Organic Debris

Regularly removing organic debris is essential for preventing the buildup of contaminants.

• Skim the Surface: Use a skimmer net daily or as needed to remove leaves, insects, and other floating debris.
• Brush the Walls and Floor: Brush the sides and bottom of the pool at least weekly to dislodge dirt and debris, allowing the filter to capture them.
• Vacuum the Pool: Vacuum the pool regularly to remove settled debris.

Step 4: Check and Maintain Your Filter

Poor filtration is a silent killer of water quality.

• Filter Cleaning Schedule:
  • Sand Filters: Backwash when the pressure gauge reads 8-10 PSI above the clean operating pressure, or at least once a month.
  • Cartridge Filters: Clean the cartridge when the pressure gauge reads 8-10 PSI above the clean operating pressure, or as recommended by the manufacturer. This usually means taking it out and hosing it down.
  • DE Filters: Backwash when the pressure gauge reads 8-10 PSI above the clean operating pressure, then recharge with new DE.
• Filter Media: Ensure your filter media (sand, cartridge, or DE powder) is in good condition and hasn’t reached the end of its lifespan.

Step 5: Optimize Circulation and Run Time

Proper circulation ensures that chemicals are distributed and debris reaches the filter.

• Pump Run Time: Aim to run your pool pump for at least 8-12 hours per day, and up to 24 hours during a shocking treatment. This ensures all the water in your pool is filtered and sanitized.
• Check Skimmer and Pump Baskets: Clean out any debris from these baskets regularly.
• Ensure Jets Are Pointed Correctly: Direct jets downwards and in a circular pattern to promote good circulation throughout the pool.

Step 6: Monitor and Maintain Water Balance

Consistent water testing and adjustments are key to preventing recurring problems.

• Regular Testing: Test your water at least 2-3 times a week, and daily during periods of heavy use or when addressing an issue.
• Adjusting Chemicals: Use pH increaser/decreaser, alkalinity increaser, and calcium hardness increaser as needed to keep levels within the ideal ranges.

Preventing Future Fishy Smells

Prevention is always easier than cure. By implementing a consistent maintenance routine, you can significantly reduce the chances of your pool smelling like fish again.

Consistent Sanitization

• Maintain Free Chlorine Levels: Keep your free chlorine level within the ideal range (1-4 ppm) at all times.
• Regular Shocking: Even without a fishy smell, shocking your pool periodically (e.g., monthly during the swimming season) can help prevent chloramine buildup.

Diligent Cleaning

• Daily Skimming: Make a habit of skimming your pool surface every day.
• Weekly Brushing and Vacuuming: These tasks are crucial for removing settled debris before it has a chance to decompose.

Managing Bather Load

• Encourage Pre-Swim Showers: Ask swimmers to shower before entering the pool to rinse off excess oils, lotions, and sweat.
• Consider a Pool Cover: A pool cover can significantly reduce the amount of organic debris that enters the pool from the environment.

Advanced Treatments (Optional)

• Enzyme Treatments: Pool enzymes can help break down non-living organic contaminants like oils and lotions, reducing the load on your chlorine.
• Phosphate Removers: If you have persistent algae issues, testing for and treating high phosphate levels can be beneficial.

Summary Table of Causes and Solutions

Problem	Primary Cause	Solution
Fishy Smell	High chloramines (trichloramines)	Shock pool, increase circulation, test and balance water, remove organic debris.
Green Water	Algae bloom	Brush pool, shock pool to a very high level (20+ ppm), vacuum dead algae, maintain proper chlorine levels, check for water imbalance.
Cloudy Water	Poor filtration, high chloramines, fine debris	Clean filter, shock pool, ensure adequate circulation, check and balance water, use clarifier if needed.
Irritated Eyes/Skin	High chloramines or very low/high pH	Shock pool to break down chloramines, test and balance pH.
Musty/Earthy Smell	Early stage algae bloom, decaying organic debris	Brush pool, shock pool, remove debris, ensure proper sanitization and circulation.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Q1: Is a pool that smells like fish dangerous to swim in?

A: While not immediately dangerous, a strong fishy smell indicates that your free chlorine is depleted and unable to effectively sanitize the water. This means bacteria and other harmful microorganisms could be present. It’s best to avoid swimming until you’ve corrected the issue.

Q2: Can I swim in my pool if it smells slightly fishy?

A: A very faint, fleeting fishy smell might be acceptable if your free chlorine levels are still adequate. However, if the smell is persistent or strong, it’s a sign to take action before swimming.

Q3: How long does it take to get rid of the fishy smell after shocking?

A: After shocking, it typically takes 24-48 hours for the smell to dissipate, provided the pump is running continuously and the chlorine levels are allowed to return to normal swimming ranges.

Q4: My pool still smells like fish after shocking. What did I do wrong?

A: Several factors could be at play: you may not have used enough shock, the water imbalance (especially high pH) might have prevented the shock from working effectively, your poor filtration might be allowing contaminants to re-enter quickly, or there was an overwhelming amount of organic debris and contaminants. Retest your water and consider another, stronger shock treatment with proper water balance.

Q5: How can I prevent my pool from smelling like fish in the future?

A: Regular maintenance is key. This includes consistent skimming, brushing, vacuuming to remove organic debris, maintaining proper water imbalance, ensuring adequate pump run time for good circulation, and keeping your filter clean.

By following these guidelines, you can maintain a sparkling clean and odor-free swimming pool, ready for you and your family to enjoy all season long.