Top 5 Bowfishing Arrows: Your Essential Buying Guide

Ever watched a gar streak through murky water and thought, “I wish I could catch that”? Bowfishing offers that thrilling chance! But once you have your bow ready, the next big hurdle appears: choosing the right arrow. It can feel like you’re drowning in choices. Should it be heavy or light? What about the point style? Picking the wrong arrow can mean missed shots and wasted energy, turning an exciting hunt into a frustrating chore.

This confusion stops here. We understand the struggle of finding arrows built to handle tough fish and deep dives. This post cuts through the confusion. We will break down everything you need to know about bowfishing arrows—from shaft materials to tip designs.

By the end of this guide, you will confidently select arrows that fly true, penetrate deep, and bring home the trophy. Get ready to upgrade your success rate on the water!

Top Bowfishing Arrow Recommendations

Bestseller No. 1
BOWSOUL 34inch Bowfishing Arrows Luminous with Broadheads and Safty Slides for Compound Bow&Recurve Bow Fishing Arrow Archery Hunting (Pack of 6) (White)
  • 【Noctilucent】 High-quality Bowfishing arrows glow at night to help you see where the fish are.
  • 【Features】Arrow Length: 34.8inch in total; OD: 8mm; Weight: 104g. Solid arrow shafts, not easily broken
  • 【Safety】Come with Stopper and Safety Slides installed,lncreased accuracy in archery good choice for bowfishing activity, The nocks are fixed with qlue,please noted.
  • 【Broadheads】 Professional bowfishing broadhead with barbs, with pins on the shaft to keep the broadhad in place. Nickel plated stainless steel arrow point is durable and has strong penetration.
  • 【Package】 Package include 6pcs bowfishing arrows, and extra two set of accessories.
Bestseller No. 2
TIGER ARCHERY 34inch Bowfishing Arrows Solid Fiberglass Shaft with Broadhead for Compound Bow and Recurve Bow Fishing Arrow Archery and Hunting (Pack of 6) (Green)
  • 【Visibility】Hi visibility color solid fiberglass shaft
  • 【Broadheads】Nickel plated stainless steel arrow point is durable and has strong penetration
  • 【Features】Arrow Length: 34.8inch in total; OD: 8mm; Weight: 104g.
  • 【Safety】Come with Stopper and Safety Slides installed,Increased accuracy in archery good choice for bowfishing activity, The nocks are fixed with glue,please noted
  • 【Package】Package include 6pcs bowfishing arrows, and extra one set of accessories.
SaleBestseller No. 3
AMS Bowfishing Fiberglass Arrow-White w/Chaos FX Point & AMS EverGlide Safety Slide
  • Chaos FX Point is all Stainless Steel, with 2 hardened barbs that open to nearly 2" of holding power.
  • Includes Replaceable Cyclone Tip for great penetration. Release Barbs by loosening the tip, no need to remove.
  • Solid White Fiberglass Shaft checked for straightness for more a more accurate shot!
  • AMS EverGlide Safety Slide Installed
  • Made in the USA!
Bestseller No. 4
Bowfishing Arrows 34inch Solid Fiberglass Shaft with Broadhead for Compound Bow Recurve Bow Fishing Arrow Archery Hunting (Pack of 3)
  • High Quality Fishing Broadhead with 2 mechanical barbs ,desing offers over 2.5" of holding area and releases by loosening the tip.Colorful solid fiberglass shaft.
  • 32 inch Solid Fiberglass Shaft, 34.4 inch Length in total, 8mm O.D. Shaft with Safety Slide & Stopper increased accuracy in archery good choice for bowfishing activity. Weight: around 100g each arrow.
  • Compound & Recurve bows & Long bows , fit for fish hunting, target practice & outdoor shooting.
  • Nocks are fixed by glue, please noted.
  • Packaged of 3/6 pieces fishing arrows, money back or replacement is available.
Bestseller No. 5
KEAUP 6 Pack 32 inch Bowfishing Arrows Luminous with Broadheads and Safty Slides Bowfishing Bow for Compound Bow Recurve Bow Fishing Hunting
  • High-Quality Bowfishing Arrows Set: 6 Pack, 35inch in total, OD: 8mm, Weight: 100g. Solid Fiberglass Bowfishing Arrows, 6 Pack broadheads, and safety slides for a comprehensive bowfishing experience
  • Luminous Bowfishing Arrows: The glow in the dark runs the full length of the shaft and it is easy to charge up with a good high-output flashlight or a UV flashlight
  • Precision Bowfishing Broadhead: Equipped with sharp broadheads for accurate shooting and effective penetration, ideal for targeting fish with precision
  • Safety: Come with Stopper and Safety Slides installed to prevent arrow snapback and protect your fingers. Ideal for both novice and experienced bowfishing enthusiasts
  • Versatile Compatibility: Designed to be compatible with both compound bows and recurve bows, ensuring flexibility for various archery setups
Bestseller No. 6
6 Pack 32 inch Bowfishing Arrows with Broadheads and Safty Slides Bow Fishing Arrow Luminous for Compound Bow Recurve Bow Fishing Hunting
  • High-Quality Bowfishing Arrows Set: Includes 6 Pack 32inch Solid Fiberglass Shaft, 6 Pack broadheads, and safety slides for a comprehensive bowfishing experience
  • Luminous Bow Fishing Arrows: The glow in the dark runs the full length of the shaft and it is easy to charge up with a good high-output flashlight or a UV flashlight
  • Precision Bowfishing Broadhead: Equipped with sharp broadheads for accurate shooting and effective penetration, ideal for targeting fish with precision
  • Safety: Come with Stopper and Safety Slides installed to prevent arrow snapback and protect your fingers. Ideal for both novice and experienced bowfishing enthusiasts
  • Versatile Compatibility: Designed to be compatible with both compound bows and recurve bows, ensuring flexibility for various archery setups
Bestseller No. 7
TIGER ARCHERY 34inch Bowfishing Arrows Solid Fiberglass Shaft with Broadhead for Compound Bow and Recurve Bow Fishing Arrow Archery and Hunting (Pack of 6) (Blue)
  • 【Visibility】Hi visibility color solid fiberglass shaft
  • 【Broadheads】Nickel plated stainless steel arrow point is durable and has strong penetration
  • 【Features】Arrow Length: 34.8inch in total; OD: 8mm; Weight: 104g.
  • 【Safety】Come with Stopper and Safety Slides installed,Increased accuracy in archery good choice for bowfishing activity, The nocks are fixed with glue,please noted
  • 【Package】Package include 6pcs bowfishing arrows, and extra one set of accessories.
SaleBestseller No. 8
Muzzy Bowfishing 1020-C Classic Fish Arrow with Carp Point - Nock Installed White
  • Quality bowfishing arrow setup for soft-fleshed
  • Premium grade solid fiberglass Classic Arrow with a quick release 1018 Trocar tipped Carp Point
  • Arrow pre-drilled for cable or string attachment
  • Glue on nock is installed
  • This is a great arrow for general bowfishing applications, making it a good arrow for beginning bowfishermen.

The Ultimate Bowfishing Arrow Buying Guide

Bowfishing is an exciting way to hunt fish. You use a specialized bow and arrow to catch your quarry. Choosing the right arrow makes a big difference. This guide will help you pick the best bowfishing arrow for your needs.

Key Features to Look For

When you shop for a bowfishing arrow, look closely at a few important things. These features help the arrow perform well in the water.

  • Shaft Material and Strength: The arrow shaft must be strong. It needs to handle hitting water at high speed and pulling heavy fish. Aluminum or fiberglass shafts are common. Some high-end arrows use carbon.
  • Point/Tip Type: The tip is crucial. Most bowfishing arrows use a barbed point. Barbed points grip the fish tightly so it doesn’t slip off. Make sure the barbs retract easily for safe travel.
  • Fletching (Fins): Fletchings help the arrow fly straight before it hits the water. They are usually made of durable plastic. They should be securely attached.
  • Safety Slide/Stopper: This is a very important safety feature. The slide keeps the line from tangling around the bow handle or your fingers when you shoot. It slides down the shaft upon release.
Important Materials

The materials used directly affect how long your arrow lasts and how well it shoots.

Aluminum: Aluminum arrows are popular because they are tough and affordable. They bend more easily than carbon but are very resistant to breaking on impact with hard objects like rocks.

Fiberglass: Fiberglass arrows are often heavier. Their weight helps them push through the water better, especially in murky conditions. They are very durable against water damage.

Carbon: Carbon arrows are very light and fly very straight. However, they can sometimes shatter if they hit a hard underwater object, which makes them less forgiving than aluminum.

Factors That Improve or Reduce Quality

Good quality arrows last longer and shoot more accurately. Poor quality arrows can fail when you need them most.

Factors Improving Quality: Look for seamless shaft construction. This means there are no weak spots where the arrow might break. High-quality barbed tips deploy quickly and lock securely. Good quality arrows often have bright colors, making them easier to see underwater or on the bank.

Factors Reducing Quality: Arrows with thin walls break easily. If the point screws on loosely, it might fall off during the shot. Fletchings that peel off after just a few shots show low quality. Rust on metal parts also reduces the arrow’s lifespan.

User Experience and Use Cases

How you plan to use your bowfishing gear affects your choice.

Shallow Water Hunting: If you shoot in very shallow, clear water, you need a lighter, faster arrow. Accuracy matters more here because you are shooting at shorter distances.

Deep or Murky Water: For deeper or dirtier water, a heavier arrow shaft is better. The added weight helps push the arrow through the resistance of the water quickly. You might need a brighter colored shaft so you can spot it after the shot.

Beginners vs. Experts: Beginners should choose durable, affordable aluminum arrows. Experts might prefer the speed of carbon or specialized heavy fiberglass arrows for specific conditions. Always ensure the arrow weight matches your bow’s draw weight for safe shooting.


Bowfishing Arrow FAQs

Q: How long should a bowfishing arrow be?

A: Most bowfishing arrows are about 30 to 32 inches long. This length works well with standard bow setups. Always check your bow manufacturer’s recommendations.

Q: Do I need a reel attached to my bowfishing arrow?

A: Yes, almost always. The line attaches to the safety slide on the arrow shaft. The line spools onto a bowfishing reel mounted on your bow. This lets you retrieve the fish after you shoot it.

Q: What is the difference between a barbed point and a chisel tip?

A: A barbed point has hooks that grab the fish and hold it. A chisel tip is sharp and stabs the fish, but it often lets the fish slip off unless you pull it in very fast. Barbed points are much more common for reliable catches.

Q: Can I use a regular target arrow for bowfishing?

A: No. Regular target arrows lack the strength and the specialized barbed tip needed for bowfishing. They will likely break or fail to hold a fish.

Q: How do I maintain my bowfishing arrows?

A: Rinse your arrows with fresh water after every use, especially if you shoot in saltwater. Check the barbs and make sure they move freely. Inspect the shaft for any bends or cracks before you shoot again.

Q: What color arrow is easiest to see underwater?

A: Bright colors like neon yellow, orange, or green are usually the easiest to track through the water.

Q: Does the arrow material affect how deep it penetrates?

A: Yes. Heavier arrows (like thick fiberglass) push through water resistance better, leading to deeper penetration than lighter carbon arrows, assuming the same launch speed.

Q: Is it safe to shoot arrows into the water?

A: It is safe if you use the correct gear. Always use a safety slide and keep your fingers clear of the line. Never shoot toward people or property. Water slows the arrow down quickly, but it still travels fast near the bow.

Q: How do I safely retract the barbs on the tip?

A: Most tips have a mechanism you press or twist while holding the shaft. Always point the tip away from your body when retracting the barbs.

Q: What is the purpose of the safety slide?

A: The safety slide stops the fishing line from wrapping around the bow handle or your hand when you shoot. This prevents tangles and potential injury. It is a vital safety component.