Baitcaster Vs Spinning Reel Pros and Cons | Which One Should You Choose?

Baitcaster Vs Spinning Reel Pros and Cons | Which One Should You Choose?

Once line and hook used to do all the fishing but now a lot of tools have availed which definitely made fishing more enjoyable and easy.

With the increasing amount of tools, the debate also growing. There are a lot of arguments going on regarding different fishing items which do not seem to come to an end.

And today I have come here with one of the most argued topics and that is, baitcaster or spinning reel? Which is the better one for fishing?

Many people have their strong opinion on this. Some like baitcaster and some spinning.

However, in this very article, I am going to show you baitcaster vs spinning reel pros and cons. Not only pros and cons, but everything about these reels that an angler must know.

So with that said, let’s get started with it.

Baitcaster Vs Spinning Reel In-depth Comparison

Both of these reels are widely used and comes with their own set of benefits and drawbacks. If you are a new angler who is figuring out which reel to pick or a professional one who want to switch to a different kind of reel, this very comparison is going to wipe out all your confusion for sure.

Baitcaster Reel

Starting with the baitcastig reel. These are also called as Baitcaster and they are around for long. Baitcaster sits on the top of the rod and other reels sit down the rods, with this you can mark which one is a baitcaster and which is not.

These reels are advanced fishing reels and also designed for professional anglers. It offers high control and sheer degree of precision which is why this reel is not for a newbie or intermediate anglers.

The spool moves when you cast, so you should have enough capability and power to move the spool. Even professional anglers need to do a lot of practices before using baitcaster.

Baitcaster reels are hard to control but nevertheless why most people are after these reels? The durability and strength baitcaster offers, no other reel does. This reel’s spool has the ability to hold the heavy line that you might use to catch big fishes.

If you are planning on to catching big fishes, you are going to need a baitcaster. It would give you great accuracy and control. But in order to enjoy baitcasting you need skills.

Plus, for long distance casting, there is no better alternative than a baitcaster reel, it has a great line holding capacity.

However, if you are a newbie angler who just stepped into the fishing world, I would suggest you, don’t even think about baitcasting. Spend some more time in fishing, gather some basic skills and then you might shift into that.

Benefits of Using a Baitcaster Reel


Angler’s always looking for lightweight items so that they can travel to distances easily and fish for a longer period of time without getting tired. One best advantage of using a baitcasting reel is, it is very lightweight. Some models are as light as a newborn bird.

If you combine this reel with a lightweight rod, you are going to get rid of arm fatigue. You will be able to cast for a longer period of time.

Baitcaster’s are 30 to 50% more lightweight than the spinning reels. Some high-end baitcaster reels weight only 5 to 7 ounces.

The higher line holding capacity

These reels can hold a high amount of lines. If you are planning onto go for deep water or long distance fishing, there is no way without a baitcaster reel. Baitcaster’s has the capacity to hold a high amount of heavy reels that no other reels have.

Spinning reels does offer a good line holding capacity but that is far less than baitcasting reels. You will be able to cast twice the distance of a spinning reel with a baitcaster.

So need something for distance casting? Baitcaster is the thing.

Power & Strength

A spinning reel is nowhere near baitcasting reels in terms of power and strength. Even a small baitcaster reel can deliver more drag power than a giant-sized spinning reel, and that is why baitcaster reels are for big fishes.

Moreover, they are highly durable too. You should not face any issue with your baitcaster reel if you maintain that regularly.


These reels are also very popular for the accuracy they offer. Accurate casting largely depends on the skill but if the reel doesn’t support then that skill won’t going to work. The combination of both is what behind every accurate casting.

Baitcaster reels come with a spool release button which loosens the spool when the button is pressed. And once you have cast, you can also control the line manually putting your finger on the spool, the spool will stop immediately.

This control and accuracy are much needed when fishing for bass. If you don’t have control over the line and cast, there is a high chance that the hook will get stuck with the trees or bushes.

Drawbacks of Baitcasting Reels

Hard to Control

Controlling baitcasting reels are very tough. It takes a lot of experience and skill to use these reels smoothly. That is why these reels are definitely not a choice for newbie anglers.


These reels are outstanding and you are going to enjoy your entire fishing trip if you are skilled in baitcasting. Another problem with these reels are, they are very expensive.

Spinning Reels

And on the other hand, spinning reels are for newbie and professional anglers who plan to catch small to medium size fishes. These reels are surely not as durable as baitcasting reels but still, it got some features that made this reels also very popular.

As I said above, these reels are for catching small or medium size fishes, and for that, you really don’t need a highly durable reel. I mean it’s good to have a durable one but not necessary to have the durability of a baitcasting reel.

Lightweight line and smaller lures are suitable for these reels since you are not supposed to go after big fish species. With a spinning reel, you can catch wide varieties of fish species, except big ones obviously.

Backlashing is a great issue and the worst situation for new anglers. With a spinning reel, you can say bye to backlashing forever. You can change the handle of these reels, so if you are left-handed you can adjust the handle to the right.

Lastly, these reels are mounted under the rod allowing gravity to set it on the perfect resting position. They are usually heavier than the baitcasting reels but there are some lightweight spinning reels too. Have a look at our top ultralight spinning reels.

Benefits of Using a Spinning Reel

Easy to Use

Spinning reels are not hard to control like baitcasting reels. These reels are perfect for all the anglers who want to catch small or medium size fishes. Operating these reels is also very easy, they have a very simplest mechanism.

All you have to do is open the bail, cast and close the bail, that’s all. But for the accurate cast, you do need at least basic casting skill.


Spinning reels comes at a lower price which enables young and beginner anglers to get their hand on a nice fishing reel easily.

Handle swapping

Spinning reels will allow you to swap handle. Doesn’t matter which handed you are, you can set the handle according to your comfort. And the process is also very simple, just unscrew the knob, remove the handle, and plug the handle on the other side.

No backlash

One of the major reasons why spinning reels are so popular that is because you won’t face any backlashing issue in spinning reels.

Drawbacks of Using Spinning Reels

Low line capacity

If you are using a thick line like monofilament, you will be able to capture low yards. So these reels are not for deep or long distance fishing.

Low accuracy

Spinning reels offer very low accuracy. And even if handled by a professional angler, it will take a couple of casts to throw the hook at the right position.


We have come to the end and let me make you more clear about which reel you should pick. If you are new to fishing, planning to catch small or medium size fishes and looking for something that comes with low price, then spinning reels are the right choice for you.

On the other hand, if you are a professional angler and looking for a reel that will offer you more accuracy and control, then you should go for baitcasting reels. Baitcaster reels are for catching big fishes.

So that is all. Right before you make a decision to buy any tool, do some research and know are you investing the money on the right thing. This is the mistake most newbie does, they are so excited that they don’t even think of doing some research and end up wasting the money.

However, if you are looking for lightweight spinning reels or baitcasting reels, I have something that you might need.

With that said, going to wrap up the article, hope this article did help you and will be back soon with another new article. Till then goodbye!

Related Blog

Best walleye fishing reels

best casting rods

best walleye jigging rods

best spinning rods

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.